This is an interview with Lukáš Likavčan. Lukáš Likavčan is a Slovak philosopher whose work traces the intertwined histories of scientific infrastructures, ideas, and cultures that shape efforts to sustain planetary habitability. He earned his MA in Philosophy and a PhD in Environmental Studies from Masaryk University in Brno, and also completed the postgraduate design programme The New Normal at the Strelka Institute under Benjamin Bratton. His book-essay Introduction to Comparative Planetology (2019) established him as a distinctive voice in environmental humanities, analysing visual cultures of imagining the Earth and the geopolitics of the climate emergency through figures such as the Planetary, the Globe, and the Terrestrial.
Likavčan has held research positions at the Institute of Philosophy of the Slovak Academy of Sciences (since May 2025), the Antikythera programme incubated by the Berggruen Institute (since July 2024), and as an affiliate researcher at NYU Shanghai’s Center for AI & Culture, while also teaching at UAL Central Saint Martins and Design Academy Eindhoven. He co-founded the outer-space consultancy Substrate and serves on the management committee of COST Action FOGOS, with his research increasingly engaging astrobiology, outer-space governance, and the geopolitics of computation. In 2026 he co-authored “The Planetary and its uses: Grounding political economy in an astrobiological perspective” with Adam Frank in The Anthropocene Review, further consolidating his interdisciplinary focus on the Planetary as a concept bridging astronomy, political economy, and environmental thought.
DIFFRACTIONS: Since your publication of Introduction to Comparative Planetology, your practice has expanded and branched out in various directions from academic philosophy into art and design pedagogy, from research institutions into venture partnerships, and from analyzing space infrastructures to consulting for the actual companies and agencies building them through ⠿ Substrate. I would be curious if you would have any reflections upon your work and how you situate “comparative planetology” as an epistemological object as well as your evolution in thinking about it as an ontological and political project: not just about how we know planets, but about whose planets get to exist, whose habitability gets prioritized?
Lukáš Likavčan: I am totally on board with reading my work as primarily targeting the question of habitability across various domains. In this respect, I have explored several pathways of how to operationalize my thinking, but the core remains the same – I am simply curious about what happens when we think about ecology in post-natural ways, most importantly through the dual optics of the cosmic/technological perspective. Both are extensions of comparative planetology as a methodology of thinking through metaphors and analogies that lead to some form of productive alienation, either from the planet Earth or from the notion of the human.
This does not necessarily mean I want to abandon these concepts, but to explore how they can be rendered anew as conditions for ontological and political projects. To this extent, I aim to keep my ontological and political commitments clear but rather minimal – they stem from the optics that view the planet and the human as processual, metabolic entities, which leads to my emphasis on those practices that negotiate interfaces, regimes of porosity, and degrees of autonomy, as well as those that are capable of identifying irrevocable aspects of the historical situation we are placed in, the aspects we must learn to play with (be it climate change or advanced computational technologies). ⠿ Substrate is a provisional vehicle I have built with Nick Houde (another philosopher and intellectual companion) in order to mobilize these intuitions, since in the end, my motivation is to make my thinking consequential through nudging people into strategic pivots or interventions into the real world. A lot of that is some form of mediation, say between different disciplines or institutions: astronomy to philosophy, philosophy to design, museum to outer space agency, and so on.

DIFF: You’ve held faculty positions at NYU Shanghai, collaborated with the Center for AI & Culture, and drawn deeply on Dunhuang’s legacy as a “Silk Road-style trading of cosmologies” in your work on dark matter. How has the experience of living and teaching in China, moving between the ancient crossroads of Dunhuang and the contemporary global hub of Shanghai, reshaped your understanding of what it means to “trade cosmologies” across intellectual traditions today? How does the experience of being a philosopher of the “planetary” while embedded in a specific, non-Western locality, with its own histories, infrastructures, and epistemic commitments, inform your understanding of what “planetary” actually means?
LL: Well, what makes me sometimes hesitate about the planetary vocabulary is how it got to be used in recent years as a sort of facelifted version of liberal globalism. I find that quite disturbing, because first, it is an anachronism, and second, it reifies the planetary, which should be primarily a processual category. In my upcoming book, I’m dealing with this indirectly by simply saying that the planetary is a transitory concept, its aim is to take us somewhere else, as a sort of ladder that helps you climb somewhere to assume a different point of view. This point of view is cosmic: treating the planet as one among many, thinking about terrestrial ecology as a particular permutation of the ways the planet can be.
That’s my mantra then: there is no planetary without the extra-planetary, no ecology without the cosmic perspective. In this respect, I am open to treating the “cosmic” in both senses of the cosmology identified by Lisa Messeri: “scientific cosmology” and “cultural cosmology”. After all, the most reasonable way to treat science seems to me is to think of it as a particular culture of knowledge-making, one that is pretty much organized globally today, but is also inevitably composed of an intersection of local idiosyncrasies (and what I mean here is that when we say “Western”, it is also a cultural constellation that is parochial, local, geographically contained and contingent). So in my thinking, I wish to simulate the non-modern cultural situation of which the Silk Road is so emblematic: it was an intellectual highway, an engine of horizontal cultural exchange spanning East and Central Asia, the Indian subcontinent, the Middle East, Northern Africa and some parts of Europe. Both scientific and cultural cosmologies have travelled on this highway, embodied in commodities, precious manuscripts, stories, and people on the road. Again, as you can see, my emphasis is on the practices of mediation here: understanding points of potential future contact or past historical influence between conceptual systems and points of view endemic to different cultural zones on our planet.
My role in this is somewhat infrastructural. When I was writing on comparative planetology in the pre-covid world, I was thinking about geopolitics as something that ultimately rests on infrastructures rather than state formations and international institutions, and although states turned out to be prime movers of effective epidemiological policies or military incursions in recent years, I still hold the position that all these operations just show that infrastructures are the ultimate armature of governance, state or non-state. In this sense, understanding infrastructures of knowledge-making (from satellite systems to ancient monasteries) means understanding what kind of power they enable, or how they can be productively repurposed.
DIFF: Could you introduce your collaborative project After Silicon, which engages the material substrate of digital culture? If silicon-based computation is approaching physical limits and post-silicon futures such as quantum, biological, and optical computing demand new material ecologies, how do you assess the potential rupture this creates in the technosphere and beyond? Are you imagining a genuinely post-silicon future while also describing a present where silicon’s logic has become so naturalized and embedded that it is no longer visible as silicon? And as an independent project, do you envision it as critical making and speculative narrative to inspire public imagination, or as a critical framework for near-term policy and design decisions?
LL: The point of After Silicon was to trial a kind of consultancy-style research memo with my old friend from the Strelka days Christopher Burman (currently he co-leads a studio at UCL Bartlett). I was inspired by conversations with some Shanghai-based private investors who have been quite bullish about biotech (if you look at the state of Chinese biotech, there are many good reasons to be bullish about it). Speaking in global terms, at the speculative edge of biotech today is biocomputing, especially brain organoids developed by firms such as Cortical Labs or FinalSpark, which basically promise to leverage the computing capacities of biological neurons for speedy and energy-efficient information processing at scale.
Another speculative tech that had some limited success is DNA memory storage, although so far this is quite a cumbersome technology that needs far more additional research to become at least a theoretically meaningful data storage option. Our aim was to make a philosophical case for why the convergence of technology and biology should matter today as a pathway for diversification of computational substrates, which would in my opinion unlock a very different approach to where distributed intelligence can come from – instead of relying on one genre of silicon-based computational intelligence, we could mix and match different substrates according to their affordances.
One day, you can perhaps have a curated database of your favorite films downloaded in your left index finger and unlock with it an invite to the party in a sauna club warmed up by the residual heat from the nearby datacenter, who knows. After Silicon is in this respect a showcase of conditions for growing scenarios about near-term future technological pivots, and this is also where it becomes relevant to policy or design decisions, because when it comes to institutional strategies or allocation of R&D investments, not everyone wants to take the path of the least resistance and instead may wish to bet on very oblique socio-technological developments to emerge. In this respect, my scenario fiction piece Organoid Nation – which I wrote for the Hemispherical Stacks online volume at the MIT Press Antikythera journal, which I also had the pleasure to co-edit with Chen Qiufan and Benjamin Bratton – is a spiritual successor of After Silicon, deploying a vision of near-future independent Scotland taking charge of a global manufacturing hub for biocomputing and nanotech.

DIFF: Your essay Trading Cosmologies Today, on emptiness (空), dependent origination (缘起), and non-duality (不二) in contemporary philosophy of dark matter, juxtaposes the Heart Sūtra’s concept of emptiness with dark matter. What makes this pairing philosophically productive? Does the essay argue Buddhism can ‘solve’ a type of thinking about the mystery of dark matter or propose a different contribution? In what sense is dark matter a dependently originating phenomenon, what does it mean that it is stabilized by an epistemic apparatus, and how does this reframe its reality?
LL: I don’t think that Buddhism solves the mystery of dark matter. It is however a good epistemic framework to deal with the seemingly disturbing reality of substances posited in science to explain certain phenomena without having any clear picture of what the nature of this substance is – we have clear cosmological evidence that some thing or force is causing the models of the evolution and the overall structure of the universe diverge from earlier assumptions about its composition, and so we have these extra ingredients in the models now, i.e., dark matter and dark energy, that do the trick and bring the models in tune with the observed reality. In this respect, using the Buddhist terminology of emptiness and dependent origination is motivated by the problem of how to live at peace with the stipulated, speculative nature of these “mysterious” ingredients.
In the Emptiness school of Mahayana Buddhism, emptiness simply refers to the fact that all phenomena lack any substance on their own terms – they causally originated from some precedent phenomena, but those are in turn also caused by something else, so technically speaking, this emptiness of all phenomena is just the result of the infinite causal regress. Here we can see why dependent origination is so useful in the philosophy of dark matter cosmology – first, it comments on the indexical, indirect nature of our evidence of dark matter (we infer its existence from the behavior of visible, baryonic matter), and second, it helps us to treat it as a legitimate cosmological category despite its provisional, postulated nature.
Beyond that, it also points to the dependency of our very possibility to stipulate the existence of dark matter on the scientific infrastructures of sensing and modelling the universe – this is exactly how I would understand the “stabilization” of dark matter via epistemic apparatuses, because we are here locked in this game of stipulating an entity based on prior observation in order to build apparatuses meant to further reinforce the scientific case for stipulating this entity. So there is an interesting feedback loop between the model and reality, constructing a scientific perspective that is at the same time pertinent to the real but also heavily socially and historically conditioned.
DIFF: Could you unpack the central argument of your paper Substrate-Agnostic 3x (Biosignatures, Technosignatures, Ecologies) and give a rudimentary definition of the substrate-agnostic ecology framework for readers unfamiliar with it? You note that approaches like the assembly index, which measures a system’s temporal depth, are theoretically robust and interesting yet difficult to operationalize for remote observation, whereas epsilon machines currently have an upper hand because they can process time-series data from existing instruments. Does this practical asymmetry create a selection pressure within SETI, steering researchers toward what is detectable rather than what is theoretically sound? If so, could this risk reintroducing a terrestrial bias through the back door, or privileging signatures that fit our current instruments and observational strategies rather than signatures that might genuinely reflect alien ecologies understood as substrate-agnostic niche-constructing relationships?

LL: There is really a lot to unpack here. I’ll start with the definition of substrate-agnostic ecology (SAE). In his 1866 monograph General Morphology of Organisms, Ernst Haeckel first defined ecology as “the entire science of the relationships of the organism to its surrounding external world.” The whole point of SAE is to broaden the scope of ecology outside of the zone of organisms as we standardly understand them in terrestrial biology. This means on the one hand opening towards astrobiological eventualities of heterodox, non-carbon-based lifeforms, such as silicon-based lifeforms and forms of life that operate on wildly different metabolic or genetic profiles.
This is the first kind of substrate-agnosticism – what matters is not the substrate, the concrete biochemical instantiation of life, but the broad recognition of the given entity as living in some standard or non-standard form. Its interaction with the environment then can be reasonably assumed to be pertinent to ecological interpretations. On the other hand, however, SAE is an attempt to bypass the question of what life (in a broader or narrower sense) is, and simply focus on interactions between environments and agents, whereas by agents I mean any entity that displays goal-oriented behavior.
From the astrobiological point of view, what I basically propose is to focus on signs of agency rather than signs of life (biosignatures). What motivates me to do so is that at its most generic, life is a thermodynamic phenomenon that maintains itself through internal and external modifications which display some level of dynamic regularity – metabolic patterns, environmental change via niche construction etc. Especially the latter matters a great deal to me, because niche construction undermines the artificial x natural duality – there are of course better and worse environmental modifications, but you cannot judge them by the level of their artificiality/naturalness. Therefore, it also does not make sense to strictly speaking differentiate between technological and non-technological environmental modifications.
As for detectability and observational bias, I believe that observational bias is to some extent a necessary function of any situated subject in the world – the initial fixation on a narrow scope of detectable phenomena can help us to bootstrap more generic observational programs. However, this does not mean preventing the necessary course corrections as our knowledge grows, it is just about the pragmatics of having to start somewhere. Theoretical exploration is vital here, because it hypothesizes cases of phenomena outside the range of current observational programs. Think about black holes – they were originally postulated as theoretical constructs, and only later confirmed by evidence.
The same may be the case for heterodox non-terrestrial ecologies or alien intelligences – they must be conceptualized and theorized in order to feed potential agendas of observational programs. So I argue for some healthy back-and-forth between theory and observation, which also holds when the observation brings no results, as in the case of SETI, because the apparent failure to find any signs of extraterrestrial intelligence says a lot about those assumptions we base our observational programs on. The Great Silence may be in itself information about how to set up parameters of our search, for example when it comes to what we judge to be the sign of life or intelligence, and therefore what our underlying theories of life or intelligence are. This is exactly where I argue for more generosity that comes with substrate-agnosticism, and the current emphasis in astrobiology on the search for agnostic biosignatures partly vindicates this proposal.

DIFF: Moreover, you affirm AI as a nonhuman creative agent forcing design and architecture to abandon human-centric definitions of artifactuality. Do you see the contemporary development of artificial intelligence effectively serving as a terrestrial laboratory for substrate-agnostic technosignatures? And if so, does the fact that we struggle to detect or define agency in our own machines suggest that the search for extraterrestrial technosignatures also faces an even deeper epistemological problem than the search for biosignatures?
LL: I don’t think the epistemological problem is deeper here – my proposal is to search for signs of agency that cut across extraterrestrial biosignatures and extraterrestrial technosignatures. Substrate-agnostic ecology suggests a more generic epistemic stance. Even if you wish to stick to the duality of biosignatures and technosignatures, you end up at least with a partial conclusion that any technosignature may be a substrate-agnostic biosignature, because there is no necessity (to my knowledge) that would force certain kinds of biology to produce only certain kinds of artefacts.
DIFF: In a recent post on your company’s Substack, you question whether outer space governance will ever settle into a “single coherent space order,” suggesting instead a “messier stack of overlapping technical interventions by states, firms, and alliances”. How does this messy, infrastructural reality challenge traditional, Earth-bound notions of “geopolitical orders”? And does the very concept of a “substrate” help us understand why politics above the Kármán line might “come in the form of infrastructure” rather than treaties?
LL: We can return to Introduction to Comparative Planetology and infrastructural geopolitics to understand this thesis better. First of all, territorial notions of sovereignty become less relevant here. Perhaps they will make some sense on the Moon or Mars, but also in those cases, territorially bound sovereignty will be a function of one’s ability to deploy infrastructures on the ground – sovereignty will be a function of infrastructural capacity. Earth’s orbit provides the clearest case, since territoriality is completely non-existent here outside of strictly confined infrastructural pockets (spacecraft, space stations). If you are on the deck of a US spacecraft, your actions must follow US jurisdiction, but what if you go on a spacewalk? Are the spacesuit and its life-support system an extension of this infrastructure, and therefore do they fall within the same sovereignty?
In the case of the Moon, despite territorial appropriation being ruled out by the Outer Space Treaty, landing a spacecraft or building some infrastructure may constitute an act of claiming a certain territory, as far as some multilateral agreements such as the Artemis Accords go – these for example establish a mechanism known as “safety zones”, which enable exclusion of activities by other parties in the given zone for the reasons of operational safety. What we see here is a mixture of overlapping institutional and infrastructural regimes, different “ordering attempts”, to use the words I have borrowed from one interview with Adam Tooze. So you see, infrastructures are here the unavoidable substrate of sovereignty, simply speaking.
DIFF: In your article Is the Solar System a Wilderness or a Construction Site?, you argue that “conservation is not the opposite of construction but one of its modalities”. How does this reframing, which moves from a “conservationist” to a “constructivist” paradigm, change the ethical calculus surrounding the militarization and commercialization of space? If the solar system is not a pristine wilderness to be preserved but a dynamic “construction site”, does that make military installations or resource extraction more justifiable, or does it simply shift the terms of the debate?
LL: This article is still undergoing some revisions, as it is in the peer-review process at one journal, but the basic argument still holds. My motivation is not to justify military installations or resource extraction, but to nudge the emerging debate in space environmentalism away from rehearsing classical arguments in environmental protection debates that rely on an appeal to nature as something pristine and therefore good and therefore inherently worth protection in its untouched state. It matters to me what positions we adopt in order to build ethical and regulatory frameworks; they are not ontology-free. If any celestial body as well as the solar system at large represent a kind of evolving, processual entity, conserving it in a certain state sounds like a violation of its intrinsic dynamics, not protection – after all, extraneous, ecological factors always play some role in unfolding any evolutionary trajectory.
Moreover, if we stick to the conservationist framework in outer space environmentalism based on a notion of wilderness borrowed from the terrestrial domain, we are relying on a very troubled, West-coded notion, one that ultimately draws on the modernist nature-culture duality: nature is the source of virtue, culture corrupts it by artificial interventions (recall Rousseau or 19th century romanticism). I prefer to be a constructivist in the sense of seeing the solar system as an evolutionary process with human activities fully involved, because we are the emergent agents within this system, not a landing party from the outside. Humans are byproducts of the billions of years of evolution of cosmic matter in this tiny corner of the universe, and we cannot refrain from making hard decisions about how to responsibly steer our increased presence outside of Earth’s protective atmospheric envelope.
DIFF: What’s the next project or frontier you’re turning toward?
LL: The most immediate horizon in front of me is the publication of my book with Bloomsbury, provisionally titled Environmentalism Beyond Earth. I have been preparing this book for several years and now it is luckily at the finish line. I treat this text as the culmination of my engagement with planetary thinking that started with the “little purple book,” Introduction to Comparative Planetology.
The argument of Environmentalism Beyond Earth in a nutshell follows the mantra I’ve already stated: there is no ecology without cosmic perspective. If we wanna talk about environmental protection and sustainability, we actually have to talk about habitability as an astrobiological category – a category that applies to the case of our Earth as one particular instance of possible planetary ecologies. In the first chapter, I reconstruct the astronomical concept of the planet that treats it as a processual, metabolic entity, which spatially manifests as a layered structure of spherically packed phase gradients. The second chapter picks up the pace and accelerates into reframing terrestrial environmentalism as the question of maintaining the habitability of Earth for different kinds of agents, including those that belong to Earth’s technosphere. And the third chapter wraps it up by shifting the overall focus of the book’s argument towards unpacking what it means for humans to be a planetary subject. As I argue, we matter in the cosmic perspective as far as we treat ourselves as bodies – biological organisms – endowed with a capacity to be selfless, in a special sense of the term that denotes an ability to transcend the immunizing, ego-centric pull of our own subjectivity.
There are already many things that can follow up after this book. One thing is to transform my Long L essay from Antikythera Journal into a book project, so let’s see how that goes. I am also collecting research for a short book about hands as a design object, mostly from the perspective of robotics and prosthetics. And perhaps another one about architectures of astronomical exploration, specifically with respect to dark matter cosmology and exoplanet astronomy. I’m sure these will occupy me for the years to come, and beyond that, I mostly hope for more interesting work with clients through Substrate (which will hopefully bring me again closer to culture and art), and a couple of fun academic papers to write with other colleagues.
REFERENCES
Likavčan, L. (2019). Introduction to comparative planetology. Strelka Press.
Likavčan, L. (2025a). Is the solar system a wilderness or a construction site? Conservationist and constructivist paradigms in planetary protection (arXiv:2508.20145). arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.20145
Likavčan, L. (2025b). The long L: Habitability in substrate-agnostic ecologies. Antikythera Journal. https://doi.org/10.1162/ANTI.5D08
Likavčan, L. (2026a). Trading cosmologies today: Emptiness (空), dependent origination (缘起), and non-duality (不二) in contemporary philosophy of dark matter. PhilArchive.
Likavčan, L. (2026b). Substrate-agnostic 3x: Biosignatures, technosignatures, ecologies (arXiv:2607.01664). arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.01664
Likavčan, L., & Frank, A. (2026). The planetary and its uses: Grounding political economy in an astrobiological perspective. The Anthropocene Review. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/20530196261434014
Collaborative Projects and Edited Volumes:
Burman, C., & Likavčan, L. (n.d.). After silicon. After Silicon. https://www.aftersilicon.com
Chen, Q., Bratton, B., & Likavčan, L. (Eds.). (2025). Hemispherical stacks. Antikythera. (Contains Likavčan’s scenario fiction “Organoid Nation”)
Other Referenced Sources:
Haeckel, E. (1866). Generelle Morphologie der Organismen [General morphology of organisms]. Georg Reimer.
Messeri, L. (2016). Placing outer space: An earthly ethnography of other worlds. Duke University Press.
Tooze, A. (2025, June). World ordering instead of world orders [Keynote address]. Berlin Summit, Forum for a New Economy, Berlin, Germany.
